Understanding Our Planet Through Chemistry

Understanding Our Planet Through Chemistry

.

This U.S.Geological Survey site shows how chemists and geologists use analytical chemistry to: determine the age of the Earth; show that an extraterrestrial body collided with the Earth; predict volcanic eruptions; observe atmospheric change over millions of years; and document damage by acid rain and pollution of the Earth's surface.

.

INDEX 44385yiu54xpz9b

Foreword

I. Introduction

II. Understanding the Earth

IIa. History recorded in chemistry. How old is the Earth? ip385y4454xppz

III. Mapping the chemistry of the Earth's surface

IIIa. Assessment of public lands

IV. Can we depend on chemical analyses?

IVa. Measuring quality

FOREWORD

This document describes the role of chemistry in issues vital to our economy, health, and well-being. When we are analyzing a sample of the Earth, we never ask if a specific element is present. Virtually every sample of the Earth contains every natural element at some amount. The more appropriate questions are: How much of it is present? Is there enough to be mined profitably? In the environment, is it dangerous at this level or in this form? And after we've identified the issues that we need to solve about our planet, we then need to ask, What clues can we find that will give us the answer?

We will show you how many geologic problems are solved using routine analyses of the major components of rocks. We will also show you the complexity of analyzing trace amounts of common components in extremely small samples, such as rare samples of air from more than 100 million years ago, tiny samples of ore-forming fluids that were entombed in minerals 300 million years ago, or small amounts of naturally-occurring radioactive isotopes that are as old as the Earth. Because some elements in our environment are hazardous at trace levels, they must be analyzed down to those low levels. The impact of quality control on analyses will also be discussed, as well as the production of standard reference materials that are distributed internationally to Federal and private laboratories.

As the primary Federal Earth-Science Agency, the USGS studies and provides solutions to questions concerning our planet, assesses the mineral resources of Federal lands, and serves as a repository for geochemical data generated by numerous Federal programs. These data are being applied to new economic and environmental concerns and provide a cost effective method to solve geochemical problems, often with no impact on wilderness or fragile refuges.

---------------------------------------------------------

I. Introduction

Questions about geology -the science of the Earth- can be difficult to answer because many times we can't safely get close enough to the event. Even if we can, our senses are not sharp enough to detect everything that is happening. The Earth is relentless in its course of change, but the transformation occurs over a vast amount of time. Some geologic processes can take a million years or more to complete. We know that today's events have also occurred repeatedly throughout geologic time. To understand our planet Earth, we need to read and interpret the permanent records in the Earth's crust and interior. These records are the key to the future, and many of these clues are preserved in the chemistry of geologic samples.

Everything we touch in our daily lives is made up of elements. There are 92 elements that occur naturally, and in most cases, the human senses cannot recognize these elements when they are present in a compound. If, for example, we could always recognize what something is made of, there would be no such thing as "fool's gold" (a natural combination or iron and sulfur called pyrite). Because we have difficulty identifying these relatively pure compounds, it's not surprising that when rock or soil contains only a very small amount of an element we are incapable of recognizing the element's presence.

Using only our vision, pyrite is easily confused with gold, so much so that the common name for pyrite is "fools gold."

Using analytical chemistry, we can even determine trace elements (elements present at very low levels) at the parts per million (ppm) or parts per billion (ppb) level. It's difficult to comprehend the concentration of a substance at this low a level. To get a mental picture, imagine an average 3-bedroom home. It would take about 1 million marbles to cover the floors of the home. One part per million would be represented by just one marble among all the other marbles. For that same marble to represent one part per billion, however, it would take 20 football fields covered with marbles.

Different elements have different physical properties. These properties determine what methods can be used to analyze each element (or group of elements). The methods described in the WWW document can be applied to many different geological problems, but no one method can solve every problem. The analytical methods described here are only a few that were selected to show the role of chemistry in geology.

---------------------------------------------------------

II. Understanding the Earth

IIa. History recorded in chemistry

How old is the Earth?

The question of when the Earth was formed and when various events on it occurred has long fascinated humanity. In the past, various estimates of the age of the Earth have been made using the available technology. All estimates of this type changed drastically with the modern application of radioactivity.Return to this point in index.

Elements, isotopes, and radioactivity

Matter is made up of atoms, and atoms are made up of a complex array of subatomic particles. Let's consider only three of these particles: protons (positively charged), neutrons (no charge), and electrons (negatively charged). Every element has a fixed number of protons that cannot be changed without creating a different element. If, for example, we add a proton to an atom of sulfur, it becomes heavier and is now an atom of chlorine. If we change the number of neutrons in an atom, however, it has almost no effect on the chemical properties and outward appearance but does have an effect on the atomic mass. It can also have an extreme effect on the atomic stability of the element. If we take an atom of potassium that has 39 neutrons in it and add one more, the atom now becomes unstable and can radioactively decay.

Each combination of an element with a different number of neutrons is called an isotope. Isotopes that are radioactive disintegrate or decay in a predictable way and at a specific rate to make other isotopes. The radioactive isotope is called the parent, and the isotope formed by the decay is called the daughter. A radioactive isotope decays at a constant rate proportional to the number of radioactive atoms remaining. A simple way of describing the speed of decay is to see the time it takes for half of the atoms of a radioactive parent to decay and form the daughter element(s). This is called the half life. Various events (especially melting of the rock) will cause the isotopes in a rock to redistribute. When the rock solidifies it can be thought of as starting a stopwatch. By determining the amount of the parent and daughter isotopes present scientists can determine when the stopwatch started.

Naturally occuring radioactive isotopes (called the parent isotope) disintegrate at specific rates to make other isotopes (called daughter isotopes). The amount of time it takes for half the quantity of the original isotope to decay is constant, no matter how much as present at the beginning. Based on this principle, the age of geologic events can be measured.

As an example, the parent-daughter system used to determine the age of the Earth is the uranium-lead system. The decay of the parent uranium isotopes to daughter lead isotopes in samples of the Earth, Moon, and meteorites indicates that all the planets in our solar system formed 4.5 billion years ago.

While determining the age of the Earth is intriguing, radiometric dating has recently been useful in more practical issues like the following: With what age of granite formation are ore deposits in a particular region associated? How recently has a fault been active, and is it likely to be safe to build near it now? How often does a volcano erupt and how often do landslides recur?

On May 18, 1980 the Cascade volcano, Mt. St. Helens, erupted exposively causing a great deal of destruction and a number of deaths.

In addition to telling us the Earth is 4.5 billion years old, geologic dating can answer important questions such as: When was the last time a fault moved? What areas are a safe place to construct a nuclear reactor? How frequently does a particular volcano erupt? Is a volcano nearing an eruptive part of its cycle?

Because different isotopes of an element have different masses, they can be viewed as an arrangement of masses in a spectrum. An instrument that separates and electronically measures a spectra of atomic masses is called a mass spectrometer. There are many types of mass spectrometers, but the most frequently used in earth-science age determinations are magnetic sector mass spectrometers. These magnetic spectrometers operate on the principle that if you put an electric charge on an object and throw it into a magnetic field, the object s path will form a circle. The radius of the circle will depend on the strength of the magnetic field and the mass of the charged atom divided by its electric charge. Thus, if you have a purified portion of an element from a sample with several isotopes, each can be made, in sequence, to travel the same circular path to the detector by varying the strength of the magnetic field. Magnetic sector mass spectrometers consist of at least three components as illustrated in this figure. (1) A source of sample ions, (2) a magnetic field, and (3) a detector.

The atoms on the filament are ionized and accelerated at a specific velocity through a magnetic field, causing them to take a specific curved path depending on the ion's mass. This type of mass spectrometer scheme most commonly used in geologic dating shows how ions with a specific mass are directed into the collector for counting, while others, like a race car taking the curves at the wrong speed, are lost.

A difficult chemical procedure is used to concentrate the element of interest so that isotopes can be measured on a mass spectrometer. In many cases the recovered amount is no larger than a spot on the sample filament and could pass through the eye of a needle. Return to this point in index.

Digesting rocks

But how do you take a rock and purify a portion of it for mass spectrometry, and how do you analyze a rock sample on an instrument that only analyzes liquids? In most cases, before a rock s chemical composition can be determined, it must pass through both a physical and a chemical preparation to free the element(s) of interest from the rock and present them in a dissolved or liquid form.

Initially, fist-size pieces of rock are broken down to pea-size fragments using a crusher with steel jaws. A pulverizer grinds this coarse material into a powder as fine as flour.

Next, the powder is further broken down, or decomposed, by using either an acid treatment or fusion. During this chemical decomposition, the weighed sample of powdered rock releases its elements into solution.

Because most rocks are composed of a combination of many types of minerals, each having different chemical and physical properties, digestion is accomplished by using a combination of acids. Most commonly used is a mixture of hydrofluoric, nitric, hydrochloric, and perchloric acids, which will decompose all but the most resistant minerals. The acids are heated with the sample powder in Teflon containers, on a hot plate, or in a specially designed microwave oven.

In the fusion technique, a powdered inorganic reagent (known as a flux) is mixed with the rock powder and heated above the melting point of the flux; the molten flux then attacks the sample and decomposes it into a uniform melt. The melt may then be poured into a mold and cooled for methods that require a uniform solid such as X-ray fluorescence spectrometry (scroll down to picture of arm pouring red hot samples for a discussion of XRF) or dissolved in a diluted acid to create a liquid solution. The higher temperatures (500 to 1,200 C) and caustic nature of the molten chemicals used for fusions increases the efficiency of the decomposition as compared to acid techniques and renders most minerals soluble. Each form of sample decomposition, acid or flux, has its advantages and disadvantages that must be considered. In addition, the importance of safety and simplicity must not be ignored.Return to this point in index.

Disaster from space

One of the mysteries of the history of the earth is the layer of clay that was deposited around the entire globe 65 million years ago. The layer marks the K-T boundary the end of the Cretaceous and beginning of the Tertiary periods. It is best known as the time when not only the dinosaurs but nearly half of all life forms became extinct.

Chemical evidence in this layer of clay preserved from 65 million years ago in Caravaca, Spain, indicates an asteroid or comet struck the Earth at up to 170 times the speed of sound, possibly causing a disaster resulting in the extinction of half of all life forms, including the dinosaurs.

At the beginning of the last decade, Nobel Laureate Luis Alvarez and his team members discovered a 9 ppb abundance of the element iridium while using neutron activation analysis to study 1-cm-thick samples at the K-T boundary layer. The fact that the high level of iridium coincided exactly with the classic end of the Cretaceous mass extinction event led them to propose a theory linking these two observations. They theorized that an asteroid between 6 and 14 km in diameter struck the Earth, and the impact lofted enormous amounts of pulverized target material high into the Earth s atmosphere. They speculated that this dust- size, impact ejecta caused an environmental catastrophe.

Under a microscope, these quartz grains show lines that are characteristic of high shock and are found only with meteorite impacts or atomic explosions. This 1/3 millimeter grain is from the K-T boundary clay at Teapot Dome, Wyoming.

Additional research by other scientists suggests that if the extraterrestrial object was an asteroid, it most likely impacted the Earth at a velocity of 50 times the speed of sound and measured 15 km in diameter. Because asteroids of this size are very few in number in our solar system, the object could also have been a comet, most likely moving even faster, possibly 170 times the speed of sound but measuring only 10 km in diameter.

To test the impact theories, we have applied a new analytical technique called laser ablation, inductively coupled plasma, quadrupole mass spectrometry (LA-ICP-QMS). To allow efficient, rapid, spatial sampling, a laser is used. The technique is highly sensitive for almost all elements.

As depicted below, the energy of the laser is focused onto a spot about 80 micrometers in diameter (slightly more than the diameter of a human hair) to vaporize and sputter material from small zones of the sample. The operating conditions of the laser range from 1 million to 1 trillion watts per square centimeter. This incredibly high energy density is created when the energy is packed into small bursts of 160 microseconds, which are then focused with a lens onto a very small spot.

A laser ablation, induction coupled plasma, quadrupole mass spectrometer vaporizes a small spot on the sample. The vapor is then ionized in the plasma. The four charged rods (the quadrupole) then cause only the appropriate ions to arrive at the detector for counting; all others are lost. By changing the electric charge on the rods, different elements can be determined.

The vapor from the sample is then carried by a stream of argon gas into a 7,000 C argon plasma, where the vapor is ionized. These ions are then drawn into a quadrupole mass spectrometer (QMS). The QMS consists of two sets of electrically charged, machined rods. A radio-frequency signal is applied to both sets of rods. Under specific operating conditions, one unique, mass-to-charge ratio of ions will be directed down the opening between the four rods and exit to the detector. All other ions will be lost.

Based on these 250- micron-wide, black laser trails across the brown layer of clay from the K-T boundary in Caravaca, Spain, the quadrupole mass spectrometer found abnormally high abundances of platinum-group elements (up to 1,000 ppb), most likely coming from an extraterrestrial source.

The LA-ICP-MS is sensitive for all the platinum group elements (PGEs) that would appear from an asteroid impact. The laser, which has fine sampling resolution, was used to sample the 1-cm layer analyzed by Alvarez and coworkers but in bands only 0.25-mm thick. In this way, we were able to sample just the layer of PGE-enriched material and found the concentration in this zone to be nearly 1 ppm, a factor of 100 times higher than that previously reported. This greater concentration of the PGEs gives additional support to the theory that an extraterrestrial body collided with the Earth 65 million years ago. Return to this point in index.

IIb. Geologic processes

Volcanoes

Volcanoes erupt when molten rock (magma) deep in the Earth s interior makes its way to the surface. On average, for every cubic kilometer of magma erupted from a volcano, 3 to 10 cubic kilometers are stored beneath the surface in shallow reservoirs called magma chambers.

We can see what these magma chambers look like by studying ancient reservoirs that have solidified and been exposed by erosion. One of these is Half Dome in Yosemite National Park.

Half Dome, in Yosemite Park, is the remains of a magma chamber that cooled slowly and crystallized beneath the Earth's surface. The solidified magma chamber was then exposed and cut in half by erosion. Similar, still molten magma chambers are thought to underlie many active volcanoes.

The degree of violence of an eruption depends principally on the chemical composition of the magma. Of major importance is the interplay between the proportion of silicon dioxide (SiO2 or silica ), which controls the viscosity of the magma, and volatile components, such as water, carbon dioxide, and sulfur dioxide. Magmas that are poor in silica usually release their gases non- explosively and produce slow-moving lava flows, like those commonly seen in Hawaii. Although such eruptions can be destructive, humans can usually avoid the lava flow and are rarely threatened by such volcanic activity.

Low silica magma, typical of Hawaiiain volcanoes, produces lava flows that move slowly and can rarely overtake a human who wants to escape.

Because buildings and structures can not easily be moved out of harms way, even slow moving lava flows can cause significant property damage.

Under certain conditions, however, the magma and surrounding rocks are blown apart by the release of volatiles, resulting in a dangerous explosive eruption, as happened on May 18, 1980 at Mount St. Helens, near Portland, Oregon. With only about 0.5 cubic km of erupted magma, however, this was by no means considered a large volcanic eruption. The 1991 eruption of the Pinatubo Volcano, near Manila in the Philippines, was approximately 14 times larger, involving about 7 cubic km of magma. But even the Pinatubo eruption is relatively small compared to infrequent giant eruptions of volatile- and silica-rich magma that have occurred throughout the history of the Earth.

In the early 1900's a chemist could analyze about 200 samples per year for the major rock-forming elements. Today, using X-ray fluorescence spectrometry, two chemists can perform the same type of analyses on 7,000 samples per year.

Major-element chemical analysis is a front-line tool in the study of volcanoes and volcanic hazards. The analysis of a volcanic rock provides a fundamental common ground for comparing the styles and violence of previous eruptions of similar composition. During the first half of the 20th century, these analyses were performed exclusively by classical wet chemical analyses chemically separating each element of interest from the other elements in the sample. This procedure was extremely laborious. A good analytical chemist could analyze only a couple of hundred rocks per year for their complete major element chemistry. U.S. Geological Survey scientists now use technology called X-ray Fluorescence Spectrometry (XRF) to perform the same type of analyses.

XRF Spectrometry starts at the atomic level. Atoms consist of protons and neutrons in a central nucleus with electrons in different orbitals around that nucleus. If an electron from an inner orbital is knocked out, the vacancy created is filled by an electron previously residing in a higher orbit. The excess energy resulting from this transition is dissipated as an X-ray photon with a characteristic wavelength. In X-ray fluorescence analyses, the electron vacancies are created by bombarding the sample with a source of X-rays or gamma rays most frequently from an X-ray tube or a radioactive isotope. By detecting the characteristic X-rays that are fluoresced, the element of interest is shown to be present in the sample. The more abundant the X-rays are, the more of that element is present in the sample.

Bombarding the sample with X-radiation does not require a liquid sample. In fact, because solid samples are more stable than liquids, virtually all samples presented to X-ray spectrometers are solids. Furthermore, there is almost no permanent change that takes place in a solid sample analyzed by XRF, allowing it to be saved and reanalyzed. This is especially important for the repeated analysis of the same calibration standards over periods of years, permitting the use of the same analysis protocol. Homogeneity requirements are frequently solved by dissolving a portion of the pulverized sample in molten flux that is then poured into a mold and cooled to form a solid glass disc with a precise, flat, analytical surface.

To analyze samples by X-ray fluorescence spectrometry, samples are fused at 1120xC with a flux; the chemist then pours the molten mixture into special molds to produce solid glass discs with a precise analytical surface.

A team of two analysts, using this method, can analyze over 7,000 samples a year. Because so many more analyses are now available, geologists can answer more difficult types of questions such as what changes are happening in the magma chamber during an eruptive cycle.

At a number of frequently active volcanoes, such as Mount St. Helens (which has erupted about every 100 years), a thick and complex sequence of volcanic rocks has been deposited. Geochemists and geologists can reconstruct the eruptive history of the volcano through field studies and analyses of these rocks. They conclude that the eruptive activity at Mount St. Helens is separated by longer periods of repose. Like many other volcanoes, there are systematic changes in major- and trace-element composition through time. The 1980 eruption appears to be at the end of a chemical cycle that began about 500 years ago.

With this information we can predict the style, frequency, and warning signs of future eruptions. Newly erupted lava, pumice, or ash may then be evaluated in a historical context. In some instances, XRF analyses can be rapidly completed in less than 24 hours by express delivery of the samples to the lab and electronic transmission of data back to the volcano being examined. This is something that would have been impossible for the classic chemist.

While systematic changes in overall chemistry contribute a great deal of information about a volcano, there is still a desire to understand more about what happens deep within the Earth s crust how the magma forms and what triggers the volcano into eruption. Return to this point in index.

Application of instrumental neutron activation analysis

Some of our understanding of the source of molten magma has been obtained by analyzing rocks for a group of 15 elements called the rare-earth elements (REE). In a type of rock called basalt, the total amount of all the REE s is often less than 100 parts per million (ppm).

One well proven analytical technique used to determine the concentrations of REE in rocks and minerals is instrumental neutron activation analysis (INAA). In this technique, a rock or a single mineral that the rock contains is irradiated using a nuclear reactor. This causes the elements to become radioactive and to emit gamma rays with distinct energies. The sample is then placed on a detector that measures how many gamma-rays of these energies are emitted. The number of distinct gamma rays emitted is proportional to the abundance of that particular element.

To get better sensitivity necessary to measure rare-earth elements in specific rocks, samples can be irradiated in a low-power reactor. It turns some of the element into an unstable isotope whose decay can then be detected and counted to determine the quantity of the element in the sample.

To understand what the REE can tell us about how magmas are formed, scientists have developed mathematical formulas. These formulas suggest that when certain minerals interact with molten rock, there can be appreciable effects on the rock s REE contents. In a process called partial melting, for example, if a source rock contains minerals (such as garnet) that can hold high concentrations of certain REE, then these elements tend to be prevented from entering the molten rock. Because Hawaiian basalts have low concentrations of the heavier REE, and garnet has high concentrations of heavy REE, some Earth scientists conclude that the magmas have formed by partial melting of a source rock that contains garnet, and the garnet held back the heavy REE. Return to this point in index.

The smallest clues

To understand more about the causes of eruptions, geologists have to look more closely into the fine details of the solidified magma samples to find a record of the conditions before and during eruption. Mineral crystals within magmas vary in composition depending on the surrounding magma and the temperature at which they are formed.

Why do some volcanoes explode catatrophically with rapid, life-threatening devastation? Recent research indicates that magma does not necessarily move directly from its source to an eruption. A magma chamber may contain stable reservoirs or layers of one composition with a lower temperature. Subsequent influx and mixing of a second higher temperature lava overheats the mixture, triggering an explosion. The 1991 Pinatubo eruption appears to have been triggered because a hot, low-silica basalt magma penetrated a stable resevoir of cooler, high-silica type, forming an explosive mixture. The explosion forced the closing of Clark Naval Air Station and interrupted numerous air flights because of ash clouds that damaged engines.

Mineral compositions from the 1991 eruption of Mt. Pinatubo indicate that low-silica magma at a temperature of about 1,250 C mixed with high-silica magma (780 C) just before the eruption. Based on this information, volcanic rocks produced in previous eruptions were analyzed. The results suggest that the 1991 eruption is the latest in a series of eruptions that were triggered by the mixing of magmas. Magma mixing has also triggered eruptions at a number of other volcanoes.

Shortly after World War II, physicists in the United States, England, Germany, and Japan began to perfect a new analytical instrument called the electron microscope. Instead of producing a visually magnified image, this new instrument accelerated and focused electrons through a column of magnetic lenses onto a small spot on the sample. The ability to magnify objects is limited by the energy or wavelength of the radiation that is used to observe the object. Because the accelerated electrons from the column have a much shorter wavelength than light, it is possible to produce images at much higher magnifications than can be obtained using an optical microscope. Today, the most powerful electron microscopes can produce images at magnifications as high as 1 million times.

When electrons are accelerated into an object, they interact with the atoms in that object and produce three important types of radiation: (1) X-rays (you may scroll back to the picture of the Early 1900's Laboratory where a description of how X-rays are formed was presented for the related technique of X-ray Fluorescence), (2) the secondary electrons that are used to see the sample, and (3) back-scattered electrons, which are bounced back as a function of the mass of the sample.

In the 1950 s, the French physicists, Castaing and Guinier, developed an instrument based on the characteristic X-rays produced by the electron bombardment of the sample. This instrument can measure the number of X-rays emitted from the small spot irradiated on the sample. By counting the X-rays produced, Castaing determined the chemical composition of a portion of a sample no larger than the size of a human blood cell. This new instrument was called the electron microprobe (EMP).

During the same period of time, another instrument was brought into production the Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM). Like the electron microscope, it uses the secondary electrons created from the sample s surface to record an enlarged image of the object. Its principal advantage is that it deflects the electron beam and scans it back and forth over the sample surface (called rastering) in a pattern similar to that in which wallpaper covers a wall.

In order to see objects smaller than what normal light allows, scientists have developed an instrument that accelerates electrons. The Scanning Electron Microscope uses electromagnetic lenses to focus the electrons, since glass lenses cannot.

The secondary electrons are continuously detected, and the signal is directed to a television monitor where the image is displayed. Zooming in or backing out by changing the size of the raster area (hence changing the magnification), the scientist can use the enlarged image to aim the scanning electron microscope. At the same time, X-rays characteristic of the composition are generated. These X- rays can be detected by an X-ray analyzer and used to create a map of the element's abundance.

In this example, calcium X-rays produced from a pinhead-size sample from the 1991 eruption of Mt. Pinatubo are mapped and color coded by a scanning electron microscope to show the range of calcium content from high (white) to low (green).

Analyzing a single particle of smoke

Because of their similarities, EMPs and SEMs overlap in their capabilities. The modern EMP has become a true hybrid that combines the viewing capability of the SEM with the analytical power of the electron microprobe. Both EMPs and SEMs are capable of obtaining images at magnifications over 100,000 times. These instruments can see and then analyze something that wouldn't show up with a light microscope, such as the following single particle of volcano smoke in this picture.

After seeing the invisible, the next question is "wonder what that's made of?" "Is it bad for our health?" Small samples like this particle of volcanic smoke, the size of a single human red blood cell, can be analyzed by a scanning electron microscope in 4 minutes with errors of less than 1 percent.

Analytical chemistry in the search for ore deposits

Analytical chemistry plays a key role in our continuing quest to understand how ore deposits form and in the practical exploration for ore deposits. If you pick up an ordinary rock that builds the crust of the Earth and determine its chemical composition, for every billion atoms, 1 to 10,000 atoms will be metallic elements such as gold, silver, platinum, mercury, copper, cobalt, nickel, chromium, lead, zinc, molybdenum, tin, and tungsten. Natural processes in the Earth s crust have the remarkable ability to concentrate and purify certain rare metallic elements to form unusual deposits of minerals that contain 1,000 to 10,000 times the amounts found in ordinary rocks.

With today s modern mining and extraction technology, it has become possible to mine very low-grade deposits. For example, gold can be economically recovered from rocks that contain less than one tenth of an ounce of gold per ton of rock. But gold continues to be expensive because of the cost in locating the deposit, mining the rock, and extracting the small amount of gold in each ton of rock. All of the inorganic raw materials used to manufacture the products of today s technological society have to be either mined or recycled.

Almost every process that takes place in the Earth s crust, whether from the action of molten rock, heat and pressure at depth, hot springs or steam, running water, weather, or biological activity can contribute to the formation of an ore deposit. Geologists use the principles of chemistry to try to understand how these processes scavenge elements from ordinary rock, transport them, and concentrate them to form an ore deposit. Geologists have developed models that describe the physical characteristics and chemical composition of each ore deposit type and how they relate to the geologic environment in which they form similar to the way biologists describe how an organism fits into a particular environmental niche.

In North America and many other parts of the world, almost all of the rich ore deposits exposed at the surface have already been discovered. Most of the ore yet to be found is not visible to the human eye. Therefore, geologists have had to improve their understanding and develop more sophisticated ways to detect where ore deposits can occur.

Two main approaches are used to detect deposits hidden below the surface. One uses the ore-deposit model, and the other is based on the detection of a dispersion halo that extends for some distance from the deposit (for more discussion of dispersion halos, scroll down to the section on "Mapping the Chemistry of the Earth's Surface") .

The following analogy shows how geologists use ore-deposit models. If all but the tip of the tail of an elephant was buried by a landslide, a biologist could recognize from the skin, hair, and shape of the appendage that the tail belonged to a mammal. With advanced testing of tissue samples, a biologist could prove that the tail belongs to an elephant and could easily predict that the body should be buried about 1 meter below the tip of the tail.

Most ore-deposit models are not as advanced as biologists models for elephants, but a few are nearly so. Several copper and molybdenum porphyry deposits, located as deep as 2,000 to 4,000 feet below the surface, have been discovered based on small surface exposures measuring several feet across. These exposures were of breccia pipes (vertical pipe-shaped bodies of pulverized rock), which are known to extend thousands of feet above the main body of porphyry deposits. Because not all porphyries contain deposits of economic metals, geologists can collect and analyze field samples to determine what metals the porphry will contain, and if it is worth drilling.

Schematic cross section of a copper-molybdenum porphyry model. Explosive release of steam and gases during the cooling of the intrusion result in the formation of pipes filled with broken rock fragments that extend for thousands of feet towards the surface and often contain fragments of the ore body present at depth.

Analysis of fossil fluids and gases from tiny time capsules

A great many ore-deposit models are tied to the cause of formation of the deposit. Questions about the environmental conditions related to formation of the deposit are temperature, pressure, source of the metals, and composition of any fluids and gases that transported and formed the ore or associated minerals.

Many crystals in the Earth s crust have formed in some kind of fluid. Small quantities of the fluid that surrounded the crystals during growth are commonly trapped as tiny fluid inclusions within these crystals. In many cases, these fluid inclusions are less than 0.1 mm but record important information about the conditions when the ore was being formed.

Trapped in a time capsule the same size as the diameter of a human hair, the ore-forming liquid in this inclusion was so hot and contained so much dissolved solids that when it cooled, crystals of halite, sylvite, gypsum, and hematite formed. As the samples cooled, the fluid shrank more than the surrounding mineral, and created a vapor bubble. Heating the inclusion to the temperature at which the bubble is reabsorbed and daughter crystals dissolve gives an estimate of the minimum temperature at the moment of ore formation.

Current understanding of movements within continents reveals that throughout the Earth s history periods of large-scale fluid movements occurred in the Earth s crust. Some of these fluid migrations resulted in the deposition of metallic ore deposits and accumulations of oil and gas.

Characteristics of fluid inclusions are extremely variable. In the simplest case, when fluid inclusions cool from the elevated temperature at which they formed, the liquid shrinks and separates into a liquid and a vapor bubble. Detailed microthermometric studies give a reasonable estimate of the temperature at which the mineral was formed. Studies of this type reveal that the inclusions were trapped at temperatures from less than 50 C to over 600 C and at pressures equivalent to what is experienced at the Earth s surface and ranging to what would be found several kilometers deep.

Because of the extremely small size of so many fluid inclusions, determining the composition of the trapped fluids is difficult. First, the total amount of dissolved solids is determined by observing with a microscope the freezing/melting points of the inclusions. The sample is then crushed and rinsed with water. This water is recovered and analyzed by using a sensitive analytical technique to determine the ratios of the elements contributed by the trapped fluid. These ratios are used to calculate the composition of the fluid. The compositions range from aqueous solutions with salt content similar to rainwater to fluids with dissolved solid concentrations of over 60 percent nearly 20 times the amount found in seawater.

Analytical data on fluid inclusions are needed to understand the chemical and physical processes involved in the formation of economic mineral deposits. These data are also critical in understanding modern mineral-deposit models, which promote cost-effective mineral exploration vital to our healthy industrial economy.

Most fluid inclusions contain dissolved gases, and in some environments the inclusions consist entirely of gases. Recently, the USGS has designed a gas quadrupole mass spectrometer (QMS) that will analyze the amounts and chemical identity of gas ions in small gas samples (for more details on QMS instruments, scroll back to the QMS illustration in the "Disaster from Space" section). This instrument is extremely sensitive (8 parts per billion detection) and capable of millisecond speeds of analysis important for gas bubbles as small as 1/100 of a millimeter in diameter.

The QMS is used extensively to study ore- deposit models as well as environmental and geologic hazards. Examples include: identifying carbon dioxide as the responsible gas at the Lake Nyos, Cameroon disaster where 2,000 people suffocated in 1986; tracking atmospheric gases from bubbles in climate- study ice cores of Greenland and Antarctica; tracing dispersal of smokestack emissions and gases of geothermal energy wells and springs.

Scientists sample air trapped in the snowpack at the Greenland Ice Sheet Project 2 site in Central Greenland. These samples will be analyzed by mass spectrometry to determine the composition of ancient air. These studies help us to predict climate changes.

IIc. Environment

Global change in the geologic past

An exciting new application of the QMS instrument uses a high-energy laser fired through a modified microscope to open individual gas inclusions in ice. Ice from Greenland and Antarctica contain atmospheric gases that were captured in snow as it formed. The gases were retained as the snow turned into ice and formed bubbles. Analysis of these bubbles provides detailed information on the past composition of the atmosphere.

Sea-level changes, changes in solar activity, and, according to some astrophysicists, even the signals from distant supernovas, are also recorded in the ice. Compiling and studying this record helps us to evaluate current changes in the atmosphere and to predict future trends. Ice-core studies provide valuable information about the levels of human pollution, past climate patterns, sources of moisture, the altitude of the ice when it formed, frequency and magnitude of natural events, and biological activity at the ocean surface. Return to this point in index.

Air bubbles, amber, and dinosaurs

Ages of ice samples found on the Earth cover a span approaching 200,000 years. But how can we tell what the Earth s atmosphere was like before that? Recently, USGS scientists have used a gas QMS to determine the oxygen level of ancient samples of Earth s atmosphere from a most unlikely place amber. The fossilized resin of conifer trees, amber is interesting to scientists as a medium that traps insects, small animals, and plants, preserving them through geologic time for future study.

Amber --the fossilized resin of conifer trees--provides a unique means of protecting intricate samples of the past. This mosquito, lying trapped for 45 million years in a piece of amber, is almost perfectly preserved.

The recent extraction by scientists, of ancient DNA from organisms entombed in amber much like in the science-fiction novel and movie, Jurassic Park is an example of why scientists are intensely interested in amber. Minute bubbles of ancient air trapped by successive flows of tree resin during the life of the tree are preserved in the amber. Analyses of the gases in these bubbles show that the earth s atmosphere, 67 million years ago, contained nearly 35 percent oxygen compared to present levels of 21 percent. Results are based upon more than 300 analyses by USGS scientists of Cretaceous, Tertiary, and recent-age amber from 16 world sites. The oldest amber in this study is about 130 million years old.

This 84-million-year-old air bubble lies trapped in amber (fossilized tree sap). Using a quadrupole mass spectrometer, scientists can learn what the atmosphere was like when the dinosaurs roamed the earth.

The consequences of an elevated oxygen level during Cretaceous time are speculative. Did the higher oxygen support the now extinct dinosaurs? Their demise was gradual in the transition from late Cretaceous to early Tertiary times, as was the decrease in oxygen content of the atmosphere.

This chart shows a major decrease in oxygen content in the atmosphere from 35 percent to the present day level of 21 percent. This decrease occured about the same time that the dinosaurs disappeared--65 million years ago.

Recent methane emissions from Gulf Coast marshes

The Earth s atmosphere is still changing. Natural environmental processes (geological, biological, and geochemical) produce carbon dioxide (CO2) and methane (CH4). These gases, along with water vapor, are responsible for trapping heat at the Earth s surface.

Because biological processes are responsible for the production of methane in environments where organic matter ferments, wetlands (swamps, bogs, etc.) were previously the principal source of methane. Now, however, the combination of rice cultivation and cattle raising have taken over as the principal contributor. Studies of methane sources help us to understand their relative contributions and the factors that control the methane production and release to the atmosphere.

The studies show that when coastal wetlands are flooded by sea-level rise, salt marshes are inundated, up-slope brackish marshes become saltier, and some fresh marshes near the coast become brackish. Consequently, total methane emissions decrease because salt marshes do not produce as much methane as fresh marshes.

Fifteen miles inland from the Gulf of Mexico in a brackish marsh in Terrebonne Parish, Louisiana, methane emissions are collected in inverted buckets and measured with a portable gas analyzer. Using these measurements, scientists can determine one effect of global sea-level rise.

USGS studies of methane in Gulf Coast Louisiana indicate that brackish marshes emit between one-fourth and one-half the methane of the fresh marshes they replace during sea-level rise. The results of these local measurements in Louisiana can be used to project the world-wide effects of sea-level rise on methane emissions. By the year 2050, projected world-wide, sea-level rise will replace 50 percent of coastal fresh-water marshes with brackish water marshes. This will reduce the world s methane emissions by 2 percent. Return to this point in index.

IId. Pollution

Acid rain steals our heritage

In addition to affecting people, plants, and wildlife, air pollution also affects rocks and soils. One of the problems it causes is the degradation of buildings and monuments, especially those built out of limestone or marble. These rock types, both almost pure calcite (calcium carbonate), are commonly used throughout the world as a building stone.

These balusters, on the Pan American Union Building, Washington, D.C., were made from Georgia marble, and were installed in 1910. They demonstrate the effects of dry deposition of sulfur dioxide, which causes the formation of gypsum. Gypsum traps particulate matter to form heavy, black incrustation. In some areas, the gypsum crust has flaked off the balusters exposing a fresh but very rough surface.

Studies to determine damage caused by air pollution have pointed to changes in the acidity of the air and rain. In fact, the term acid rain is now commonly used in the media as well as scientific studies. Acid rain affects carbonate stone buildings and monuments in two ways. The first is by dry deposition of sulfur dioxide gas, increasingly contributed to the atmosphere by the combustion of fossil fuels. The gas reacts with calcium-carbonate building stone to form calcium sulfate (gypsum). As gypsum forms on the surfaces of the stone, it traps particulate matter, forming a blackened crust.

The second effect of acid rain is wet deposition. Natural rain water is a weak carbonic acid solution and all carbonate-stone surfaces that are washed by rainwater are subject to gradual erosion. This erosion is accelerated, however, by the increased acidity of rain in the eastern United States, which is often 10 times greater than in areas where acidic pollutants are absent.

Current research on acid rain is directed at defining the degree of stone damage due to both dry and wet deposition. Scientists are measuring the effects of acid rain on historic stone buildings and monuments across the country. They are exposing samples of marble and limestone to weathering at specific field sites and simulating depositional processes under highly controlled laboratory conditions.

The effects of both dry and wet deposition are evaluated by the chemical analyses of the stone surfaces before and after exposure and of rain run-off solutions collected from test slabs.

Recent research by the USGS and other agencies conducted under the National Acid Precipitation Assessment Program has shown that test samples of marble erode 15 to 30 micrometers per year, while limestone (which is less compact than marble) erodes from 25 to 45 micrometers per year. (These measurements are slightly less than those of the diameter of a human hair). Approximately 20 percent of this erosion is caused by acid rain. The remaining 80 percent is the result of the natural solubility of the stone in rain water. Because the effects of acid rain only develop over an extended period of time, high-precision analytical chemistry plays a central role in measuring these effects. Return to this point in index.

The chemistry of mine drainage

Mine drainage is water that drains from mines. The water can be of the same quality as drinking water, or it can be very acidic and laden with high concentrations of toxic, heavy metals. In general, the more acidic the water is, the poorer the water quality.

Because the chemistry of water samples can rapidly change if they are removed from the natural site, many measurements are made in the field. One of the first of these field measurements is for acidity, which is read by a meter and reported as the pH of the sample. Water with a pH of 2 has a high concentration of hydrogen ions and is acidic, whereas water with a pH of 7 is neutral. A study of mine drainage in Colorado, for example, shows that the pH of mine waters ranges from a low of 1.8 to a high of 8.

A companion field measurement made on mine water is for specific conductance. This property of water measures the electrical conductivity associated with a water sample and is useful as a quick estimate of total dissolved solids. A low number from 10 to about 200 microsiemens/centimeter (the unit of specific conductance measurements) could be considered to be drinking-water quality. Specific conductance measurement of mine waters in the Colorado study range from 100 to 38,000 microsiemens/centimeter.

The full characterization of mine water requires a number of other instrumental and analytical measurements that are carried out using both mobile and laboratory facilities. Three main, instrumental, analytical techniques are used to complete the characterization of mine-water samples. These techniques are: ion chromatography (IC), which is used to determine the concentration of fluoride, chloride, nitrate, and sulfate in aqueous samples; ICP-AES, which determines the concentration of major and trace elements(for additional discussion on ICP-AES and an illustration of the instrument, scroll down to "10,000 element determinations a day"); and liquid ICP-QMS , which is used to determine elements below the ppm level (for additional discussion and an illustration of a laser ablation ICP-QMS instrument, scroll back to the "Disaster from space" section).

Why is it so important to characterize mine drainage? Because mine- drainage water almost always flows into a stream where it can dramatically affect the aquatic organisms and the quality of the water received by downstream communities. To successfully reduce the effect of the toxic elements, their abundances must be known.

Mineral-laden water from the Argo drainage tunnel in Colorado, entering into Clear Creek, illustrates the possible environmental impact of untreated mine drainage.

From the analytical chemistry of mine drainage, scientists have concluded that the major cause of high acidity of the water is the bacterially catalyzed oxidation of the mineral pyrite. This acidity stimulates the dissolution of many other sulfide minerals, resulting in the high concentration of metals such as copper and zinc.

While it is difficult or impossible to stop mine drainage, it might be possible to cut back the rate of the introduction of toxic elements into the environment. This can be done by hindering the bacteria that speed up the oxidation of the pyrite or by neutralizing the drainage and extracting toxic elements. Recent studies have shown that wetlands can concentrate heavy metals from mine drainage. Constructed wetlands could, therefore, be used to accumulate the pollution from mine drainage. By analytical monitoring of the toxic, metal build-up in these wetlands we can avoid any impact on the wildlife that might try to live there. Return to this point in index.

IIe. Pollution Prevention

Cleaning up coal burning

While hundreds of abandoned mines across the country are releasing pollutants, active mines can also produce pollutants. Among the best examples of air and water pollution control are advances in coal technology. For years coal has been a major source of both energy and pollution in the United States. Supplies of natural gas and petroleum are dwindling. Alternative energy sources are not expected to contribute significantly to the energy needs of the United States in the near future. Coal will continue to play an important role for energy production through the first half of the 21st century.

Significant improvements in coal processing and burning in modern power plants have dramatically reduced pollution. The process has been improved in three ways. First, sophisticated equipment has significantly reduced fly ash and soot compared to the equipment used many years ago; other specialized equipment greatly reduces sulfur-dioxide emissions.

Coal, a major source of energy in the United States, does not have to cause pollution. This coal-burning power facility at Brilliant, Ohio, uses a process wherein sulfur-dioxide emissions are cut by 90 percent, nitrogen oxides by 50 percent, and carbon dioxide by 15 percent. (Photo provided by American Electric Power Service Corporation).

A second way of reducing coal pollution is by selective mining of low-ash and low-sulfur coals that pollute less. Detailed chemical analyses of coal prior to mining is required to determine the concentrations of ash, sulfur, and other toxic elements. A new multielement analytical technique that introduces the sample in liquid form to an inductively coupled plasma quadrupole mass spectrometer (ICP-QMS) is proving very useful for this purpose. This technique can determine over 70 elements at the ppm to ppb levels. To analyze coal by this method, it must first be converted to ash, fused with a flux, and dissolved. The solution is then sprayed into the 7,000 C thermal environment of an argon plasma where it is ionized. The resulting charged atomic particles are drawn into a high vacuum portion of the instrument where a quadrupole mass spectrometer (shown in Disaster from space section) separates and counts the number of atoms for each different mass.

Detailed mapping of trace elements in a coal seam may be required to locate low-polluting coal resources. The major drawback to selective mining is that only small quantities of clean coals exist, and those that can be found may be too far from power plants or too deep to be economically recovered.

The principal source of sulfur emissions from burning coal is pyrite, whose presence is shown in this photomicrograph of a coal sample.

Coal cleaning is the third method for reducing pollution. Sulfur minerals such as pyrite can be removed by using various techniques. Chemical analysis of the coal and identification of mineral inclusions determines what cleaning procedure will be most effective. This requires looking at the coal under high- power microscopes or performing tests that separate mineral and coal species by using complex physical and chemical techniques. Understanding the chemistry and mineralogy of coals has contributed significantly to the progress that has been made in recent years toward the prevention of coal-burning pollution.

For additional information on environmental geochemistry order a paper copy of Understanding Our Fragile Environment USGS Circular 1105 a publication in the Public Issues in Earth Science Series. Return to this point in index.

---------------------------------------------------------

III. Mapping the Chemistry of the Earth's Surface

IIa. Assessment of public lands

Mapping stream sediments for resource exploration

The successes of the old-time and latter-day prospectors have diminished the likelihood for the discovery of additional mineral resources on the surface of our planet. Yet our national and global dependence on mineral resources continues to grow unabatedly, and recycling can only provide a fraction of our needs. By necessity, today s search for the many minerals vital to society is focused on ore deposits that lie beneath the Earth s surface.

Earlier in this Session (back by the illustration of the copper-molybenum porphyry cross section) we discussed the use of models to locate ore deposits . Another way of locating mineral resources is by identifying element-dispersion halos. Dispersion halos are abnormal levels of the metals that develop around deposits. This halo can extend for long distan